Copycat Nutter Butters

If you have a soft spot for that irresistible peanut butter cookie everyone adores, then you’re in for a treat with this recipe for Copycat Nutter Butters. These homemade delights perfectly capture the nostalgic charm and creamy peanut butter goodness of the classic store-bought cookies, but with the warmth and freshness that only baking them yourself can bring. Imagine that rich peanut butter base, a lightly crisp edge, and a luscious, sweet filling sandwiched lovingly between two tender cookies. Whether you know the famous cookie or you’re new to it, these Copycat Nutter Butters will steal your heart — and your taste buds — on the very first bite.

Ingredients You’ll Need

Gathering simple, wholesome ingredients is the first step to unlocking the magic of these Copycat Nutter Butters. Each component serves a special purpose—from adding that creamy peanut essence to balancing sweetness and bringing just the right softness or crunch.

• Unsalted butter: Provides a rich, creamy base essential for tender, moist cookies without overpowering flavors.
• Creamy peanut butter: The star ingredient that gives these cookies their irresistible peanut flavor and smooth texture.
• Granulated sugar: Adds sweetness and helps achieve a slight crispness on the cookie surface, especially when sprinkled on top.
• Brown sugar: Contributes deep, caramel-like notes and moisture for chewiness.
• Large egg: Binds ingredients together and adds moisture to the dough.
• Vanilla extract: Enhances flavor with a warm, sweet aroma that complements peanut butter beautifully.
• All-purpose flour: The structure-builder, giving the cookies their shape and tenderness.
• Baking soda: Helps the cookies rise slightly and gives just the right texture.
• Salt: Balances sweetness and boosts the peanut butter flavor.
• Powdered sugar: Used in the creamy filling for smooth sweetness without graininess.
• Milk: Adjusts the filling’s texture to silky perfection.

How to Make Copycat Nutter Butters

Step 1: Preparing the Oven and Dough

Start by preheating your oven to 350°F (175°C) and lining a baking sheet with parchment paper; this ensures easy cookie removal and clean-up. Then, in a large bowl, cream together the softened butter, peanut butter, granulated sugar, and brown sugar until the mixture is light and fluffy—this aeration helps create an irresistible cookie texture that’s both soft and slightly crisp.

Step 2: Combining Wet Ingredients

Next, add in the egg and vanilla extract. These help bind your dough and infuse more flavor. Mix until everything is well combined and smooth, making sure your dough is beautifully uniform to guarantee even baking.

Step 3: Adding the Dry Ingredients

In a separate bowl, whisk together the flour, baking soda, and salt. Gradually introduce this dry mixture into your wet ingredients. Stir gently until a cohesive dough forms that’s soft but firm enough to shape. This balance will make your cookies hold their shape while staying tender.

Step 4: Shaping the Cookies

Roll the dough into small balls about one inch in diameter. Then gently shape each ball into an oval to mimic the classic Nutter Butter shape. Press the tops down with a fork to create that iconic crosshatch pattern, which also gives the cookies a lovely texture with every bite. Don’t forget to sprinkle a little granulated sugar on top for a subtle sparkle and a touch of extra crunch.

Step 5: Baking to Perfection

Bake your cookies for 8 to 10 minutes until they turn lightly golden around the edges. Avoid overbaking to keep them tender inside. Once baked, let them cool completely on the baking sheet — patience here will pay off because warm cookies won’t hold the filling well.

Step 6: Making the Creamy Filling

While the cookies cool, whip together the filling. Beat peanut butter and butter until creamy and smooth, then gradually add powdered sugar and vanilla extract until fully incorporated. Add milk one tablespoon at a time until the filling reaches a soft, spreadable consistency that’s just right for sandwiching.

Step 7: Assembling Your Copycat Nutter Butters

Take one cookie and spread or pipe a generous layer of the luscious peanut butter filling on the flat side. Top it with another cookie, pressing gently to make a sandwich. Repeat with remaining cookies and filling, and prepare yourself for a peanut buttery delight you won’t want to share!

How to Serve Copycat Nutter Butters

Garnishes

While these Copycat Nutter Butters shine all on their own, you can add a little extra flair by dusting them with a pinch of powdered sugar right before serving. For a festive touch, sprinkle some crushed peanuts on top of the filling before sandwiching to amp up that peanut crunch. A drizzle of melted chocolate over the assembled cookies transforms them into an elegant dessert treat.

Side Dishes

Pair these peanut butter gems with a tall glass of cold milk for the ultimate nostalgic experience. If you’re feeling adventurous, a scoop of vanilla ice cream or a bowl of fresh berries can provide a bright, creamy contrast that complements the cookies’ richness beautifully. Coffee or a nutty-flavored tea also elevate the experience for any cozy snack time.

Creative Ways to Present

For parties or gifts, arrange your Copycat Nutter Butters on a decorative platter lined with parchment and garnished with whole peanuts or mini chocolate chips. Package them in a charming tin or cello bag tied with a ribbon for a homemade gift everyone will rave about. You can even sandwich a layer of chocolate ganache alongside the peanut butter filling for a decadent twist that’s sure to impress.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

Store your Copycat Nutter Butters in an airtight container at room temperature for up to five days. This keeps them fresh and lets the flavors meld nicely. Keep them in a single layer or separate layers with parchment paper to avoid sticking and preserve their lovely shape and texture.

Freezing

If you want to enjoy these cookies longer, they freeze beautifully. Freeze the unfilled cookies in a single layer on a tray, then transfer them to a freezer-safe bag or container for up to three months. The filling can be frozen separately in an airtight container as well. When ready, thaw completely before assembling your Copycat Nutter Butters.

Reheating

To bring back that fresh-baked warmth, gently warm your cookies in the oven at 300°F (150°C) for 3 to 5 minutes, or microwave for about 10 seconds. Warm cookies with filling are an absolute delight, making the peanut butter flavor even more inviting and melty.

FAQs

Can I use crunchy peanut butter instead of creamy?

You definitely can! Using crunchy peanut butter will add a delightful textural contrast to the cookies and the filling, giving you bite-sized chunks of peanuts for an extra crunch experience.

Is it possible to make these cookies gluten-free?

Absolutely! Substitute the all-purpose flour with a gluten-free flour blend that measures cup-for-cup. Just be sure it contains xanthan gum or another binder for the best texture, and you’ll still enjoy tasty, tender Copycat Nutter Butters.

How long do these cookies stay fresh?

Stored properly in an airtight container at room temperature, these cookies stay fresh for about five days. Beyond that, freezing is your best bet to maintain flavor and texture.

Can I make the filling ahead of time?

Yes, the peanut butter filling can be made a day or two in advance and stored in the fridge. Just bring it to room temperature and give it a quick stir before spreading on your cookies.

What is the best way to get the classic oval shape?

Rolling the dough balls a bit longer between your palms into slightly elongated ovals before pressing the fork pattern is key. The fork pattern helps define the shape further and creates that signature look everyone loves.

Final Thoughts

Making these Copycat Nutter Butters is more than just baking cookies—it’s recreating a cherished classic with a fresh homemade touch. Once you experience the buttery, peanut-packed dough paired with that creamy, dreamy filling, you’ll never look back to store-bought again. So grab your ingredients, dive into this fun recipe, and get ready to share joy (and lots of peanut butter love) with everyone around you!

Print